Jurassic WarsThe world of Pangaea

Enter another world.

Six civilisations. Empires, lineages, creatures. Choose where your journey begins.

Spoiler-free reading.

What are you looking for in Pangaea?

Find a name, understand a trade or follow the relationships between peoples.

Characters, civilisations, cities, dinosaurs, trades and institutions.

Follow a first trail

Spoiler freeOpen the explorer
Korath

Institutions

Counterproof

In Korath, a major patent is only complete once a rival workshop has reproduced it and methodically attacked it.

The adversary inside the proof

A major patent is only complete after it has been reproduced and methodically attacked by a rival workshop. The rule is one of Korath’s most untouchable principles. It brings the technical adversary into validation: the rival looks for bad tolerances, failure conditions and fragile assumptions that the authors’ enthusiasm might hide. If the mechanism holds, its inventor gains far stronger legitimacy.

The registers call the scientific institution formed by these rival workshops, which reproduce and attack major patents, the Corps de la Contrepreuve.

The right to fail, the offence of false precision

The right to fail separates honest failure from concealment. A prototype can miss its goal without dishonouring the one who acknowledges the result. Hiding a margin, falsifying a trial, stealing a signature or claiming to know is, by contrast, a major scientific, social and religious offence: false precision. Revisions, accidents, amendments and limits remain readable, because Korath also reveres correction.

The season of proofs

Counterproof feeds public life. Publications, filings, counterproofs, rankings, contracts and accidents set the rhythm of a technical season followed by the public, and the scientific press publishes protocols, limits and criticism far beyond the universities. Priority claims, plagiarism, poaching, lawsuits and sabotage belong to the workshop wars; counterproof provides a recognised procedure for exposing a technical weakness, even when reputation and large financial interests are at stake.

Usable knowledge

Corrected objects, failed trials and recorded limits give professionals knowledge they can use, rather than a celebration of genius. Children are prepared early: they file small practical patents and take the Trial of the Crack, which asks them to understand and repair a damaged object.

Choosing the adversary

The counterproof begins with a designation. The Chamber chooses the rival workshop from among those who apply, setting aside any workshop linked to the author by a licence, a loan, a recent marriage or a shared backer. It looks for an adversary competent in the branch concerned, preferably a direct competitor: the one with most to gain from seeing the invention fall.

Being designated is a coveted honour. Attacking a major patent means appearing in the scientific press, proving one’s knowledge and sometimes poaching the best journeymen from the other camp. The costs of the attack are borne by the filer, who thus pays the adversary charged with contradicting him. Korathians find this perfectly normal: you pay the clockmaker who regulates your watch, and in the same way you pay the workshop that looks for the flaw in your mechanism.

Reproduce before attacking

The counterprover must first reproduce the object from the filed dossier alone, without the author’s help. This first stage is often the most feared: if the rival workshop cannot build a working copy, the dossier is judged incomplete and sent back, because knowledge that cannot be passed on through its plans is not yet a patent.

Then comes the attack proper. The rival overloads, repeats cycles until failure, neglects maintenance, swaps secondary materials, looks for the conditions the author did not announce and the misuses a clumsy user might devise. Each test is recorded with its time, its load and its result. The aim is not to destroy on principle but to find the exact limit: an invention that withstands everything except one precise condition, honestly declared, comes out of the counterproof stronger than it went in.

The signed report

The counterproof ends with a public report, signed by the counterprovers. Their names then join the patent file, just like those of the examiners: Korathian memory records who invented, who verified and who attacked. The limits found are engraved on the plaque, and the scientific press publishes the full protocol of the attack.

The signature binds the adversary too. A workshop that declared a mechanism sound, only for its weakness to show a few years later, sees its reputation damaged, especially if the flaw was within reach of a serious test. Conversely, a counterprover who invents a defect to do harm commits a fault of false precision himself. The procedure holds because everyone, on both sides, risks their name.

The War of the Thirty-One Teeth

Popular memory keeps the recollection of a famous quarrel, the War of the Thirty-One Teeth. It is told as the story of a woman apprentice who, in a single demonstration, brought down two workshop dynasties: where two great houses had been feuding for years, she showed in public what held and what did not.

Korathians love this story because it says what the counterproof promises: proof comes before rank, and an apprentice well armed with method can prevail over entire fortunes. The details vary with the taverns and workshops that tell it; the name, however, has become proverbial for a quarrel settled at a stroke by a demonstration.

Counterproof | Jurassic Wars